FT IT Review on 3G (printed 6 Oct 2004)
In South Korea, more than 50% of mobile users have 3G devices. Europe is about to start catching up, with more networks launching 3G devices in the run up to Christmas. 3G Technology, we're told, is now ready, and operators are keen to make use of the extra call capacity of 3G and hope the faster download speed will kick start a take up of data services. (p. 4).
Peter Bamford, chief marketing office, Vodafone: "Go forward a couple of years and you are going to see phones with three or four megapixel camers, CD-quality sound with storage capacity for hundreds of tracks or phones that will enable a gaming experience equivalent to any game console. This is the mobile phone industry going through in five years what the TV went through in 40 years."
Dave McGlade, CEO, O2: "I have a great deal of optimism over where 3G will go, but it has taken longer than everybody expected. Now, even if it takes just a little bit longer, I'm OK with that if it means getting the experience just right".
On the promise of video (p. 6): In South Korea, 8m users are on a SK Telecom EV-DO network with supplies data at 2.4Mbs, compared to 153kbs for CMDA2000 networks. ARPU figures for EV-DO users are three times higher than those on the CMDA network. The revenue is coming from video on demand and broadcasting. It's not just the speed, you need the right screen hardware and the right content. However, there's also the DVB-H digital TV standard, which is a more cost effective way to deliver video, while using the cellular network to carry a return single (e.g., for select content). Nokia are testing this technology.
Eduardo Claudio, director of data and content, TMN, Portugal's largest mobile operator: "We know there is not going to be any killer application for 3G but that is not the issue [...] Because 3G gives you a faster network with less latency, the experience is better than using 2.5G". In other words, existing services can be improved on 3G.
Substitution (p. 7): 3G can carry more calls at a higher quality at a lower cost. "Cost and quality are the main reasons why people do not use mobile phones more [...]". 3G should, then, increase fixed-mobile substitution (FMS). Mobile call costs have the potential to fall to just one-fifth of the 2.5G rate. Where does this leave fixed-line operators? Broadband may save them. For now, just 5% of households are mobile-only, but there's a question mark over whether people moving house will bother reconnecting their fixed line.
ARC Group report (p. 8): mobile computing will generate US$130b in data revenue by 2009 (26% will be from notebooks with 3G or 2.5G data cards). Total global market for mobile enterprise services will be US$177bn by the same time.
The FT also report that
British mobile operators are attempting to reclaim VAT on the amount they paid for 3G licensing. The case has been referred to the European Court of Justice. The question is over whether the government's sale of the licenses constitutes a economic activity in the telecoms market. The Euro VAT directives normally exclude public authorities from engaging in economic activity, except in any of 13 sectors. One of those sectors is telecommunications. Definitions of "economic activity" and "telecoms" are likely to feature in the case, which will take at least a year to play out. If the ruling is in favour of the mobile operators, then the refund would be around GBP3.35bn. (Source: FT, page 1, Oct 6 2004).